| No. |
Item |
| 1. |
0:00:15 Apologies for absence
Apologies from Cllr Linda Kirby, with Cllr John Dehaney taking her place |
| 2. |
0:00:30 Declarations of Pecuniary Interest
Cllr Najeeb Latif occasionally chairs the Design Review Panel
Cllr Russell Makin had a meeting with Russell Road residents for Item 11 Preshaw Crescent
Cllr David Dean has been working with Tooting & Mitcham FC and regard them as friends |
| 3. |
0:02:03 Minutes of the previous meeting PDF 97 KB |
| 4. |
0:03:30 Town Planning Applications
The Chair will announce the order of Items at the beginning of the Meeting.
A Supplementary Agenda with any modifications will be published on the day of the meeting.
Note: there is no written report for this item |
| 5. |
0:03:34 3 Alan Road, Wimbledon, SW19 7PT PDF 156 KB
Application number: 20/P1701
Ward: Village
Recommendation: GRANT Planning permission subject to conditions
Additional documents:
- 01) Report – 3 Alan Road, item 5.
 PDF 156 KB
- 02) Site Plan, item 5. PDF 311 KB
- 03) Site Location Plan, item 5. PDF 160 KB
- 04) Proposed Basement, item 5. PDF 126 KB
- 05) Proposed Ground Floor – Flattened, item 5. PDF 1 MB
- 06) Proposed 1st Floor – Flattened, item 5. PDF 1005 KB
- 07) Proposed 2nd Floor – Flattened, item 5. PDF 85 KB
- 08) Proposed Front Elevation – Flattened, item 5. PDF 98 KB
- 09) Proposed Rear Elevation – Flattened, item 5. PDF 98 KB
- 10) Proposed West Elevation, item 5. PDF 175 KB
- 11) Proposed East Elevation 01, item 5. PDF 175 KB
- 12) Proposed East Elevation 02, item 5. PDF 175 KB
Votes
| Cllr Christie |
Cllr Dean |
Cllr Dehaney |
Cllr Henry |
Cllr Lanning |
Cllr Latif |
Cllr Makin |
Cllr McGrath |
Cllr Southgate |
Cllr Ward |
| Not Voting |
Not Voting |
For |
For |
For |
Not Voting |
For |
For |
For |
For |
Approved |
| 6. |
0:30:09 Tooting & Mitcham FC, Bishopsford Road, SM4 6BF PDF 392 KB
Application number: 19/P4094
Ward: Ravensbury
Recommendation: grant permission subject to conditions and s106 legal agreement.
Additional documents:
- 01) Report – Tooting & Mitcham FC (1), item 6. PDF 392 KB
- 02) Site Plan – Flattened, item 6. PDF 353 KB
- 03) Proposed Site Location Plan – Flattened, item 6. PDF 729 KB
- 04) Proposed Site_Amended 27.05.20 – Flattened, item 6. PDF 1 MB
- 05) Proposed Ground Floor Amended 18.04.20 – Flattened, item 6. PDF 771 KB
- 06) Proposed 1st Floor Amended 18.04.20 – Flattened, item 6. PDF 877 KB
- 08) Proposed 2nd Floor Amended 18.04.20 – Flattened, item 6. PDF 882 KB
- 09) Proposed 3rd Floor – Flattened, item 6. PDF 911 KB
- 10) Proposed 4th Floor – Flattened, item 6. PDF 756 KB
- 11) Proposed 5th Floor – Flattened, item 6. PDF 656 KB
- 12) Proposed Roof Amended 18.04.20 – Flattened, item 6. PDF 481 KB
- 14) Coloured Front Elevation – Flattened, item 6. PDF 141 KB
- 15) Proposed Front Elevation – Flattened, item 6. PDF 467 KB
- 16) Proposed Rear Elevation – Flattened, item 6. PDF 412 KB
- 17) Coloured Side Elevation – Flattened, item 6. PDF 189 KB
- 18) Proposed Side Elevation 01 – Flattened, item 6. PDF 696 KB
- 19) Proposed Side Elevation 02 – Flattened, item 6. PDF 697 KB
- 20) Proposed Section Amended 12.12.19 – Flattened, item 6. PDF 318 KB
Votes
| Cllr Christie |
Cllr Dean |
Cllr Dehaney |
Cllr Henry |
Cllr Lanning |
Cllr Latif |
Cllr Makin |
Cllr McGrath |
Cllr Southgate |
Cllr Ward |
| For |
Not Voting |
For |
For |
Against |
Not Voting |
Not Voting |
For |
Against |
For |
Approved – To be referred under stage 2 to Mayor of London |
| 7. |
1:11:45 159 Commonside East, Mitcham, CR4 2QB PDF 278 KB
Application number: 20/P1060
Ward: Figges Marsh
Recommendation: Grant planning permission subject to a section 106 agreement for off-site affordable housing contribution, permit free development and carbon offsetting and relevant conditions.
Additional documents:
- 01) Report – Sparrowhawk Site, item 7. PDF 278 KB
- 02) Site Plan – Flattened, item 7. PDF 340 KB
- 03) Proposed Site Location Plan – Flattened, item 7. PDF 729 KB
- 04) Proposed Site_Amended 27.05.20 – Flattened, item 7. PDF 1 MB
- 05) Proposed Ground Floor Plans Amended_30.06.2020 – Flattened, item 7. PDF 2 MB
- 06) Proposed First Floor Plans Amended_30.06.2020 – Flattened, item 7. PDF 913 KB
- 07) Proposed Second Floor Plans Amended_30.06.2020 – Flattened, item 7. PDF 832 KB
- 08) Proposed 3rd Floor – Flattened, item 7. PDF 649 KB
- 8a) Proposed Roof – Flattened, item 7. PDF 558 KB
- 09) Proposed West & North Elevations Amended_23.06.2020 – Flattened, item 7. PDF 819 KB
- 10) Proposed East & South Elevations Amended_30.06.2020 – Flattened, item 7. PDF 855 KB
- 11) Proposed Sections Amended_23.06.2020 – Flattened, item 7. PDF 636 KB
- 11a) Bay Study Amended_30.06.2020 – Flattened, item 7. PDF 1 MB
- 12) Rear Axonometric Amended_23.06.2020 – Flattened, item 7. PDF 696 KB
- 13) Front Axonometric – Flattened, item 7. PDF 491 KB
Votes
| Cllr Christie |
Cllr Dean |
Cllr Dehaney |
Cllr Henry |
Cllr Lanning |
Cllr Latif |
Cllr Makin |
Cllr McGrath |
Cllr Southgate |
Cllr Ward |
| For |
Not Voting |
For |
For |
For |
For |
For |
For |
For |
For |
Approved |
| 8. |
1:37:15 37-39 Cottenham Park Road, West Wimbledon, SW20 0SB PDF 229 KB
Application number: 20/P1463
Ward: Raynes Park
Recommendation: Grant planning permission subject to conditions and the completion of a s106 unilateral undertaking to secure:
1. 5 of the 8 new units are to be parking permit free residential units.
2. The developer agreeing to meet the council’s costs of reviewing [including legal fees] the unilateral undertaking.
3. The developer agreeing to meet the council’s costs of monitoring the unilateral undertaking.
Additional documents:
- 01) Report – 37 and 39 Cottenham Park Road, item 8. PDF 229 KB
- 02) Site Plan – Flattened, item 8. PDF 302 KB
- 02a) Existing Plans_001, item 8. PDF 165 KB
- 02a) Existing Plans_002, item 8. PDF 197 KB
- 02a) Existing Plans_003, item 8. PDF 182 KB
- 02a) Existing Plans_004, item 8. PDF 170 KB
- 02a) Existing Plans_005, item 8. PDF 200 KB
- 02a) Existing Plans_006, item 8. PDF 235 KB
- 03) Proposed Lower Ground Floor Plans . Amended 05.08.2020_001, item 8. PDF 173 KB
- 04) Proposed Ground Floor Plan. Amended 05.08.2020_001, item 8. PDF 189 KB
- 05) Proposed 1st Floor Plans . Amended 05.08 (2)_001, item 8. PDF 149 KB
- 06) Proposed Second Floor Plans . Amended 05.08 (1)_001, item 8. PDF 145 KB
- 07) Proposed Plans Houses_001, item 8. PDF 228 KB
- 07) Proposed Plans Houses_002, item 8. PDF 189 KB
- 07) Proposed Plans Houses_003, item 8. PDF 176 KB
- 07) Proposed Plans Houses_004, item 8. PDF 128 KB
- 08) Proposed Flats East Boundary Elevation . Amended 05.08.2020_001, item 8. PDF 129 KB
- 09) Proposed Flats Front & Rear Elevations . Amended 05.08.2020_001, item 8. PDF 220 KB
- 10) Proposed Flats Section AA . Amended 05.08.2020_001, item 8. PDF 135 KB
- 11) Proposed Street Elevation . Amended 05.08.2020_001, item 8. PDF 146 KB
- 12) Design & Access Statement_001, item 8. PDF 84 KB
- 12) Design & Access Statement_002, item 8. PDF 145 KB
- 12) Design & Access Statement_003, item 8. PDF 289 KB
- 12) Design & Access Statement_004, item 8. PDF 213 KB
- 12) Design & Access Statement_005, item 8. PDF 264 KB
- 12) Design & Access Statement_006, item 8. PDF 204 KB
- 12) Design & Access Statement_007, item 8. PDF 53 KB
- 12) Design & Access Statement_008, item 8. PDF 36 KB
- 13) Photo 01, item 8. PDF 1 MB
- 14) Photo 02, item 8. PDF 1 MB
- 15) Photo 03, item 8. PDF 2 MB
- 16) Photo 04, item 8. PDF 2 MB
- 17) Photo 05, item 8. PDF 1 MB
- 18) Photo 06, item 8. PDF 2 MB
Votes
| Cllr Christie |
Cllr Dean |
Cllr Dehaney |
Cllr Henry |
Cllr Lanning |
Cllr Latif |
Cllr Makin |
Cllr McGrath |
Cllr Southgate |
Cllr Ward |
| For |
Against |
For |
For |
For |
Not Voting |
For |
For |
For |
For |
Approved |
| 9. |
2:28:35 115 Graham Road, Wimbledon, SW19 3SP PDF 120 KB
Application number: 20/P1275
Ward: Dundonald
Recommendation: Grant planning permission subject to a S106 agreement and conditions
Additional documents:
- 01) Report – 115 Graham Road, item 9. PDF 120 KB
- 02) Site Plan_001, item 9. PDF 390 KB
- 03) Proposed Site Plan Amended 21.07.2020_001, item 9. PDF 1 MB
- 04) Proposed 3rd Floor Amended 21.07.2020_001, item 9. PDF 541 KB
- 05) Proposed Elevation Side NE Amended 21.07.2020_001, item 9. PDF 589 KB
- 06) Proposed Elevation Side SW Amended 21.07.2020_001, item 9. PDF 630 KB
- 07) Proposed Front Elevation Amended 21.07.2020_001, item 9. PDF 692 KB
- 08) Proposed Rear Elevation Amended 21.07.2020_001, item 9. PDF 550 KB
- 09) Proposed Section AA Amended 21.07.2020_001, item 9. PDF 405 KB
- 10) Site Section Amended 21.07.2020_001, item 9. PDF 331 KB
Votes
Proposed by Cllr McGrath that flats are BELOW the minimum standard and should be rejected
| Cllr Christie |
Cllr Dean |
Cllr Dehaney |
Cllr Henry |
Cllr Lanning |
Cllr Latif |
Cllr Makin |
Cllr McGrath |
Cllr Southgate |
Cllr Ward |
| Against |
For |
Against |
Against |
Against |
For |
For |
For |
Against |
Against |
Failed
Application as presented
| Cllr Christie |
Cllr Dean |
Cllr Dehaney |
Cllr Henry |
Cllr Lanning |
Cllr Latif |
Cllr Makin |
Cllr McGrath |
Cllr Southgate |
Cllr Ward |
| For |
Against |
For |
For |
For |
Against |
Against |
Against |
For |
For |
Approved |
| 10. |
2:51:35 64-76 Kingston Road, Wimbledon, SW19 1LA PDF 163 KB
Application number: 19/P2120
Ward: Abbey
Recommendation: Grant planning permission subject to conditions and S106 agreement.
Additional documents:
- 01) Report – 64 – 76 Kingston Road, item 10. PDF 163 KB
- 02) Site Plan_001, item 10. PDF 373 KB
- 03) Site Location Plan_001, item 10. PDF 585 KB
- 04) Proposed Block Plans & 3d Views Amended 26.06.2020_001, item 10. PDF 1006 KB
- 04) Proposed Block Plans & 3d Views Amended 26.06.2020_002, item 10. PDF 1 MB
- 04) Proposed Block Plans & 3d Views Amended 26.06.2020_003, item 10. PDF 1 MB
- 04) Proposed Block Plans & 3d Views Amended 26.06.2020_004, item 10. PDF 820 KB
- 05) Amended Proposed Plans Block A_14.05.2020_001, item 10. PDF 246 KB
- 05) Amended Proposed Plans Block A_14.05.2020_002, item 10. PDF 208 KB
- 05) Amended Proposed Plans Block A_14.05.2020_003, item 10. PDF 218 KB
- 05) Amended Proposed Plans Block A_14.05.2020_004, item 10. PDF 151 KB
- 05) Amended Proposed Plans Block A_14.05.2020_005, item 10. PDF 136 KB
- 05) Amended Proposed Plans Block A_14.05.2020_006, item 10. PDF 164 KB
- 05) Amended Proposed Plans Block A_14.05.2020_007, item 10. PDF 147 KB
- 05) Amended Proposed Plans Block A_14.05.2020_008, item 10. PDF 230 KB
- 05) Amended Proposed Plans Block A_14.05.2020_009, item 10. PDF 227 KB
- 05) Amended Proposed Plans Block A_14.05.2020_010, item 10. PDF 238 KB
- 05) Amended Proposed Plans Block A_14.05.2020_011, item 10. PDF 198 KB
- 06) Proposed Plans Block B & Materials Schedule Amended 26.06.2020_001, item 10. PDF 200 KB
- 06) Proposed Plans Block B & Materials Schedule Amended 26.06.2020_002, item 10. PDF 250 KB
- 06) Proposed Plans Block B & Materials Schedule Amended 26.06.2020_003, item 10. PDF 180 KB
- 06) Proposed Plans Block B & Materials Schedule Amended 26.06.2020_004, item 10. PDF 172 KB
- 06) Proposed Plans Block B & Materials Schedule Amended 26.06.2020_005, item 10. PDF 158 KB
- 06) Proposed Plans Block B & Materials Schedule Amended 26.06.2020_006, item 10. PDF 164 KB
- 06) Proposed Plans Block B & Materials Schedule Amended 26.06.2020_007, item 10. PDF 128 KB
- 06) Proposed Plans Block B & Materials Schedule Amended 26.06.2020_008, item 10. PDF 130 KB
- 06) Proposed Plans Block B & Materials Schedule Amended 26.06.2020_009, item 10. PDF 199 KB
- 06) Proposed Plans Block B & Materials Schedule Amended 26.06.2020_010, item 10. PDF 181 KB
- 06) Proposed Plans Block B & Materials Schedule Amended 26.06.2020_011, item 10. PDF 161 KB
- 06) Proposed Plans Block B & Materials Schedule Amended 26.06.2020_012, item 10. PDF 194 KB
- 06) Proposed Plans Block B & Materials Schedule Amended 26.06.2020_013, item 10. PDF 272 KB
- 06) Proposed Plans Block B & Materials Schedule Amended 26.06.2020_014, item 10. PDF 227 KB
Votes
Proposed by Cllr Southgate that flats are OUT OF CHARACTER and should be rejected
| Cllr Christie |
Cllr Dean |
Cllr Dehaney |
Cllr Henry |
Cllr Lanning |
Cllr Latif |
Cllr Makin |
Cllr McGrath |
Cllr Southgate |
Cllr Ward |
| Against |
For |
Against |
Against |
Against |
For |
Against |
Against |
For |
Against |
Failed
Application as presented
| Cllr Christie |
Cllr Dean |
Cllr Dehaney |
Cllr Henry |
Cllr Lanning |
Cllr Latif |
Cllr Makin |
Cllr McGrath |
Cllr Southgate |
Cllr Ward |
| For |
Against |
For |
For |
For |
Against |
For |
For |
Against |
For |
Approved |
| 11. |
3:25:46 8 Preshaw Crescent, Mitcham, CR4 3GA PDF 158 KB
Application number: 19/P4118
Ward: Cricket Green
Recommendation: the application is subject to appeal for non-determination. Officers recommend to inform the Planning Inspectorate that the Council would have granted planning permission subject to conditions.
Additional documents:
Votes
| Cllr Christie |
Cllr Dean |
Cllr Dehaney |
Cllr Henry |
Cllr Lanning |
Cllr Latif |
Cllr Makin |
Cllr McGrath |
Cllr Southgate |
Cllr Ward |
| For |
Against |
For |
For |
Against |
For |
Against |
For |
For |
For |
Approved |
| 12. |
4:42:51 50 Tybenham Road, Merton Park, SW19 3LA PDF 91 KB
Application number: 20/P1732
Ward: Merton Park
Recommendation: Grant planning permission subject to conditions.
Additional documents:
- 01) Report – 50 Tybenham Road, item 12. PDF 91 KB
- 02) Site Plan_001, item 12. PDF 340 KB
- 03) Plans_001, item 12. PDF 116 KB
- 03) Plans_002, item 12. PDF 201 KB
- 03) Plans_003, item 12. PDF 237 KB
- 03) Plans_004, item 12. PDF 230 KB
- 03) Plans_005, item 12. PDF 227 KB
- 03) Plans_006, item 12. PDF 217 KB
- 03) Plans_007, item 12. PDF 188 KB
- 03) Plans_008, item 12. PDF 207 KB
Votes
| Cllr Christie |
Cllr Dean |
Cllr Dehaney |
Cllr Henry |
Cllr Lanning |
Cllr Latif |
Cllr Makin |
Cllr McGrath |
Cllr Southgate |
Cllr Ward |
| For |
Not Voting |
For |
For |
For |
For |
For |
For |
For |
For |
Approved |
| 13. |
4:08:30 33-39 Upper Green East, Mitcham, CR4 2PF PDF 358 KB
Application number: 19/P2747
Ward: Figges Marsh
Recommendation: Grant permission subject to Section 106 obligation or any other enabling agreement, and relevant conditions.
Additional documents:
- 01) Report – 33-39 Upper Green East, item 13. PDF 358 KB
- 02) Site Plan_001, item 13. PDF 392 KB
- 03) Existing Plans_001, item 13. PDF 328 KB
- 03) Existing Plans_002, item 13. PDF 226 KB
- 03) Existing Plans_003, item 13. PDF 125 KB
- 04) Proposed Plans_Amended 26.06.20_001, item 13. PDF 149 KB
- 04) Proposed Plans_Amended 26.06.20_002, item 13. PDF 216 KB
- 04) Proposed Plans_Amended 26.06.20_003, item 13. PDF 220 KB
- 04) Proposed Plans_Amended 26.06.20_004, item 13. PDF 220 KB
- 04) Proposed Plans_Amended 26.06.20_005, item 13. PDF 197 KB
- 04) Proposed Plans_Amended 26.06.20_006, item 13. PDF 183 KB
- 04) Proposed Plans_Amended 26.06.20_007, item 13. PDF 143 KB
- 04) Proposed Plans_Amended 26.06.20_008, item 13. PDF 143 KB
- 04) Proposed Plans_Amended 26.06.20_009, item 13. PDF 145 KB
- 04) Proposed Plans_Amended 26.06.20_010, item 13. PDF 187 KB
- 04) Proposed Plans_Amended 26.06.20_011, item 13. PDF 150 KB
- 04) Proposed Plans_Amended 26.06.20_012, item 13. PDF 137 KB
- 04) Proposed Plans_Amended 26.06.20_013, item 13. PDF 142 KB
- 04) Proposed Plans_Amended 26.06.20_014, item 13. PDF 128 KB
- 05) Landscape Plan_Amended 26.06.20_001, item 13. PDF 321 KB
- 06) Proposed Visualisations_Amended 30.06.20_001, item 13. PDF 239 KB
- 06) Proposed Visualisations_Amended 30.06.20_002, item 13. PDF 241 KB
- 06) Proposed Visualisations_Amended 30.06.20_003, item 13. PDF 305 KB
- 06) Proposed Visualisations_Amended 30.06.20_004, item 13. PDF 232 KB
- 06) Proposed Visualisations_Amended 30.06.20_005, item 13. PDF 225 KB
- 06) Proposed Visualisations_Amended 30.06.20_006, item 13. PDF 299 KB
- 06) Proposed Visualisations_Amended 30.06.20_007, item 13. PDF 171 KB
- 06) Proposed Visualisations_Amended 30.06.20_008, item 13. PDF 144 KB
- 06) Proposed Visualisations_Amended 30.06.20_009, item 13. PDF 199 KB
- 06) Proposed Visualisations_Amended 30.06.20_010, item 13. PDF 528 KB
- 06) Proposed Visualisations_Amended 30.06.20_011, item 13. PDF 517 KB
- 06) Proposed Visualisations_Amended 30.06.20_012, item 13. PDF 504 KB
Votes
| Cllr Christie |
Cllr Dean |
Cllr Dehaney |
Cllr Henry |
Cllr Lanning |
Cllr Latif |
Cllr Makin |
Cllr McGrath |
Cllr Southgate |
Cllr Ward |
| For |
Against |
For |
For |
For |
For |
For |
For |
For |
For |
Approved |
| 14. |
Planning Enforcement – Summary of Current Cases PDF 104 KB
Officer Recommendation:
That Members note the contents of the report. |
| 15. |
Reviews of recent changes to Town Planning legislation, and current MHCLG consultation PDF 133 KB |
